The concept of a national day of thankfulness is something I see value in. I believe that a basic frame for living our lives is thankfulness. And I believe we American’s have room to grow in our authentic thankfulness. The Thanksgiving holiday can be a time to explore and understand the myths of the ‘first Thanksgiving’ while growing our new knowledge of the American experience.
According to the Smithsonian: “The Thanksgiving myth has done so much damage and harm to the cultural self-esteem of generations of Indian people by perpetuating negative and harmful images to both young Indian and non-Indian minds. There are so many things wrong with the happy celebration that takes place in elementary schools and its association to American Indian culture; compromised integrity, stereotyping, and cultural misappropriation are three examples.”
I like to think that being reminded of the ‘Thanksgivings myth’ has the potential to lead a continuation or beginning of an authentic learning journey around this holiday. Thanksgiving can be an opportunity to learn more about the complexities of the American Indian story. It may spur a deep dive in the intricacies and realities of current and past history.
There many available resources you might tap to assist you on a learning journey. Here are a couple of resources I recommend (knowing that any and all resources have their strengths and their limits). I see both of these offerings to be valuable for their authentic focus and depth. Each is told in the first person. Each is a glimpse of the Native American experience.
On to the invitations: For teachers, young adults, and adults I recommend Brian “BB” Melendez’s podcast: Coffee With an Indian. And for teachers, parents and young adults (12 to 17), especially boys, I recommend the book: If I Ever Get Out of Here by Eric Gansworth.
Both of these recommendations are examples of material that I see as straight forward and not sanitized to down play or remove the realities of life. I like that. I know some might find either or both of these a little “raw”. Life is more than a little “raw” for many.
Melendez writes on the Coffee With an Indian web site, that this “is a tribal-social-podcast-platform for all things uniquely indigenous. Basically, we get ridiculously caffeinated—then, from a (raw) tribal perspective, intelligently assess everything! Our mission is to stimulate constructive introspection within all communities, by supporting forward thinking spaces for all people.”
Melendez captures listeners with his authentic voice and non-manicured story. It is his story, his life, and he tells it to you as your “resident Indian”. He is a Northern / Southern Paiute – Western Shoshone. Listeners will come to known him, his circle, his challenges, his triumphs and his journey. The depth and honesty of his story will draw you in. He wants to stimulate thought. He does that. He has my brain focusing on the complexity of and humanity’s connection to Native American issues. I am grateful for that. I invite you to start with episode 1 and listen to his journey.
If I Ever Get Out of Here is a novel about Lewis, who is a Native American seventh grader who lives on a native American reservation in New York state. The story takes place in the 1970s Lewis loves the Beatles and Paul McCarthy and he doesn’t have any friends. He is in the academic advanced track at school and there are no other Indians in his class. Being in this Middle School is the first time he is experiencing a non-reservation school. It is not easy to get used to the social isolation he experiences from his classmates.
A new boy, George, who lives on the military base, shows up in his class. They have similar interests and over time become friends. It is a realistic story filled with strong characters. The serious issues of bullying and cultural difference are a big part of this story. Lewis does not let George learn about his life on the reservation. On the other hand, George invites Lewis to his house and Lewis begins to learn about George’s family, their life and some of what it means to be a transient family due to the reality that George’s father can be reassigned to a new location at any time.
The bullying Lewis experiences leads to Lewis and, as time goes on, George responding. The tension and drama are real and the stakes are important.
I recommend this book because it is a good story for middle or high schoolers. And I see it as being a great catalyst for family discussions. This is the kind of novel that both the parent and the teen might want to read at the same time and discuss together.
The potential discussion topics might include: reservation life, Indian boarding schools, bullying, the Beatles, children with a career military parent, friendship, parenting, the varying status of students within a school and so many more possibilities.
The author, Gansworth, is an enrolled citizen of the Onondaga Nation; however, he grew up in the Tuscarora Nation as a descendant of one of two Onondaga women present among the Tuscarora at the foundation of the nation in the 18th century.
These two recommendations of – Coffee With an Indian and If I Ever Get Out of Here – are only possible places to start. You can ask your local librarian for others material and/or you can create internet searches to find sources you would like to investigate.
Happy Thanksgiving 2018 and may this be a good time to learn more about the complexities of the American experience